Anthony Mangieri – Una Pizza Napoletana (NYC)

Mr. Mangieri is a two-time winner (#1 ranking) in the 50 Top Pizza list and is currently on the 6th iteration of hisUna Pizza Napoletana, now on New York’s Lower East Side. He spent 9 years in San Francisco, with stints in New Jersey as well. But now Mangieri is firmly in control of his craft, limiting the offerings to just a half dozen each night with a few simple starters and a pair of desserts. It’s truly a Neapolitan worth the journey.

(Note: we are re-airing this episode on Oct. 3, 2025, since Una Pizza recently came in #1 in the U.S. and tied for #1 in the world, on the 50Top Pizza list.)

Brett Feeley – Slowhand (Toronto)

Brett Feeley did what a lot of amateur cooks did during the pandemic: make pizza. Little did he know it would lead to Slowhand – a Detroit style operation on Toronto’s East Side, where a sourdough starter is the key to a unique pie.

Chris Pandel – Zarella (Chicago)

Chris Pandel teamed up with fellow Boka Restaurant Group Chef Lee Wolen to create Zarella, a pizzeria and taverna with two styles of pizza: a thin artisan and an even thinner tavern. Pandel tackled the latter, and he’s damn proud of the results.

Jeff Scheer – Marlow (Maui)

Jeff Scheer ended up on Maui like a lot of people – by accident. But his commitment to the culinary scene there, as nascent as it is, has been admirable. We discovered his sourdough pizza at Marlow, in an upcountry mall, where the menu has lots of highlights.

Qiana & Michele Di Bari – Sal e Pepe (Lahaina, HI)

Their motto is “One Part Milan, One Part Brooklyn, All Maui,” so you know a pizza from Sal e Pepe is going to be special. This is a love story for sure, but it’s also a story of resilience and courage, in the wake of the deadly Lahaina wildfires from 2023.

Book a Tour Now